I played sports for most of my childhood and well into college. Softball, volleyball, seasons of practices, games, tournaments, and the familiar rhythm of being part of a team. From the outside, I suppose I looked like an athlete. But I’m not sure I ever fully identified as one until I was in my thirties. For a long time, that identity felt borrowed.
Sports were something I did, something I was good at, and something my family wanted for me. There were parts of it I loved, of course, but there were also expectations wrapped up in it that made it difficult to distinguish what I wanted from what other people wanted for me.
And when the seasons ended, when there was no longer a team to report to or a competition on the calendar, I wasn’t entirely sure what being an athlete meant anymore. It took years, and a great deal of experimentation, to find my own relationship with movement. I discovered strength training, yoga, roller derby, and eventually an entire career built around helping people find their own way to move through the world.
Somewhere along the way, being an athlete stopped being something I had to prove. It became part of how I understood myself. Not because I competed. Not because I looked a certain way, or achieved a particular level of fitness. But because I had decided that being physically capable, adventurous, strong, and willing to challenge myself was important to the life I wanted to live. I finally had an identity that belonged to me, and that distinction has shaped the way I coach people ever since.
The annual migration to the gym
Every year, we see it. Here in Tahoe, our version of the New Year’s fitness rush doesn’t necessarily arrive on January 1. Sometimes it’s February. Sometimes it’s March, or even May when the snow season starts winding down and people begin thinking about summer. Occasionally, the calendar and human behavior align perfectly, and January brings the familiar surge.
Class attendance rises. The gym gets busier, especially during peak hours. My personal training, and coaching calendar starts filling with people ready to make changes. After more than a decade of owning a fitness business, I can practically predict the rhythm, and I love it.
I know there’s a tendency in the fitness industry to roll our eyes at the resolution crowd, but I’ve never understood that attitude. People becoming interested in their health is a good thing, regardless of what prompted them to walk through the door. The more interesting question isn’t why people start, it’s why some people stay.
Over the years, I’ve watched people enthusiastically commit to a new routine, disappear for several months, and return when something sparks their motivation again. I’ve also watched people who initially seemed uncertain or even reluctant become the familiar faces who quietly build their lives around movement. They’re not necessarily the strongest people in the room. They’re not always the most disciplined, either. They travel, get sick, have demanding jobs, raise children, and experience all the same disruptions everyone else does, but something about their relationship with movement is different.
They aren’t perpetually trying to become someone who exercises. They’ve come to understand themselves as someone who does.
What separates the regular from the occasional visitor?
I think a significant part of the answer is identity. And identity, at least the kind that helps us make lasting changes, begins with clarity about how we want to live. When someone comes to me wanting to get in shape, one of my first questions is usually some version of: Why?
Not because improving your fitness isn’t a worthy goal on its own, but because the answer often reveals something much more interesting than a number on a scale or a desired body-fat percentage. I’ve worked with snowboarders who didn’t want to spend the first month of every winter rebuilding the strength and stamina they’d lost over the summer. They wanted to step onto their boards each season feeling as though they’d picked up where they left off.
I’ve coached parents who wanted to run the school 5K alongside their children without wondering whether they’d make it to the finish line. They weren’t particularly interested in becoming runners. They wanted to be the kind of parent who could say yes when their kid asked them to join.
I’ve worked with middle-aged mountain bikers who understood that the sport they loved required more than time in the saddle. They wanted the strength, mobility, and resilience to keep riding the trails they loved while reducing their risk of injury. And I’ve worked with people well into their seventies who had no interest in slowing down simply because another birthday had passed. They wanted to keep cycling, snowshoeing, traveling, and participating in the communities that made their lives meaningful. None of these people needed to identify as a competitive athlete, they needed to recognize what mattered to them and how physical fitness could support it.
Spoiler...it doesn’t have to be about sports at all! Maybe you want to be the person who can carry their own suitcase through an airport, explore a new city on foot, and say yes to an unexpected adventure. Maybe you want enough energy at the end of the workday to do something other than collapse onto the couch. Maybe you want to feel comfortable getting down on the floor to play with your grandchildren, then getting back up without giving it much thought. Or perhaps you want to be someone who honors their commitments to themselves. Someone who manages stress without sacrificing their health. Someone who feels capable and confident in their own body, whatever that body looks like.
You can be a casual yogi, a serious mountain biker, a muscle mommy, a weekend hiker, a dancer, or a little bit of everything. There isn’t a hierarchy of legitimate identities here. The question is whether the things you’re doing are connected to the person you actually want to be.
Identity is built through evidence
I think this is where a lot of well-intentioned advice about identity gets it wrong. We’re often told to simply start thinking of ourselves differently. Tell yourself you’re an athlete. Call yourself a healthy person. Become the kind of person who never misses a workout, but an identity that exists only in our imagination is difficult to sustain when reality gets inconvenient.
Our beliefs about ourselves are influenced by our experiences. We learn who we are, in part, by observing what we repeatedly do. If you want to believe you’re someone who prioritizes their health, you need opportunities to see yourself doing exactly that, and those opportunities don’t have to be particularly impressive:
You scheduled a workout and showed up, even though it wasn’t your best performance. You took a walk after a stressful day instead of abandoning the evening altogether. You made time for a strength session during a busy week, even if it was shorter than you’d planned. You returned to your routine after an illness, vacation, or difficult season without treating the interruption as evidence of failure. Each experience gives you another reason to believe that this is something you do. Over time, those experiences accumulate.
Psychologist Albert Bandura called attention to the importance of mastery experiences in building self-efficacy, our belief in our ability to succeed at a particular task. Successfully doing something, especially when it requires some effort, can strengthen our confidence that we can do it again. This is one reason I am so much more interested in helping clients build repeatable behaviors than in orchestrating a few spectacular weeks of effort.
A dramatic transformation might get your attention. But a year of consistently showing up, adapting, learning, and recovering can fundamentally change how you understand yourself, and here’s an important distinction: Consistency doesn’t mean that you never stop. It means that stopping temporarily doesn’t require you to start your identity over from scratch.
A cyclist is still a cyclist when the weather keeps them indoors. A person who values strength doesn’t suddenly lose that value because they take a week off to recover, or two weeks off to travel. A healthy lifestyle has to be spacious enough to accommodate an actual human life. That’s what makes it sustainable.
You don’t need to become someone else first
One of my favorite conversations, which I’ve had with more people than I can count, goes something like this:
“I’d love to work with you, but I think I need to get in shape first.”
Every time, I have to laugh a little.
What do you think we’re going to do together?
It’s a remarkably common belief that we need to reach some minimum level of readiness before asking for help. We want to lose a little weight before hiring a coach, improve our fitness before joining a class, or develop some discipline before committing to a routine. As though the entire point of coaching weren’t to help us navigate those very things. I understand the impulse. Nobody enjoys feeling like a beginner, particularly in an environment where they imagine everyone else already knows what they’re doing... but readiness is not something you have to earn.
You don’t need to become more athletic, more disciplined, more confident, or more knowledgeable before taking the first step toward a life that matters to you. In fact, taking that step might be how you develop those qualities. Make the appointment. Sign up for the class. Put the walk on your calendar. Tell someone what you’re working toward.
You might be surprised how much easier it becomes to follow through when you have a little structure, some accountability, and another human being invested in your success, and, for what it’s worth, we’ll probably have some fun together, too.
There’s no magic in January
January is a convenient cultural starting line. So is Monday. So is the beginning of a new month, the end of ski and snowboard season, your next birthday, or the moment your schedule finally settles down, but none of these dates possesses any special ability to change your behavior.
The calendar can provide a useful prompt. It cannot provide your purpose. That has to come from you. And maybe that is the most useful question we can ask ourselves as another year approaches. Not What do I need to fix about myself? or even What goals should I set?
But What kind of life do I want to participate in, and how do I want to show up for it?
Once you have an answer, you can begin collecting evidence that you’re capable of living that way. One class. One walk. One commitment kept. One decision to return when life interrupts. You don’t have to wait until January. You don’t have to wait until you’re fitter, lighter, less busy, or more motivated. You already have everything you need to begin, exactly as you are. The person you want to become doesn’t need to arrive before you take action. Sometimes (in fact I think often), you discover that person by showing up.
NBC-HWC | ACSM-CPT
Mental PEAKS: Find Your Why. Then Find the Evidence.
Find Your Why. Then Find the Evidence.
Research on self-efficacy suggests that successfully completing manageable challenges helps build confidence in our ability to follow through. Rather than waiting to feel like the person you want to become, give yourself opportunities to practice being that person.
Try this exercise:
1. Picture your future. Imagine yourself five or ten years from now. What do you want to be able to do? Where do you want to go? Who do you want to share those experiences with? Get specific.
2. Define how you want to show up. Complete this sentence: “I want to be someone who __ because __.”
For example: I want to be someone who stays physically capable because I want to explore the mountains with my family for decades to come.
3. Choose one piece of evidence. What’s one manageable action you can take this week that supports that identity? Make it specific enough to schedule and realistic enough that you feel at least 8 out of 10 confident you can follow through.
4. Notice what you did. At the end of the week, ask yourself: What did I do that supports the person I’m becoming? Look for evidence of effort, follow-through, problem-solving, and returning after interruptions.
You don’t need to reinvent yourself. You need opportunities to recognize yourself in the things that matter to you. The goal isn’t to prove you’re perfect. It’s to build a body of evidence that you can trust yourself!
Join us for Power in Practice 2027
|
|
The Dolomites Are Calling! 🇮🇹
Nine guests are already joining us in Italy next spring, and I couldn’t be more excited about the group we’re bringing together!
Power in Practice is heading to Latsch, South Tyrol, May 30–June 5, 2027, for seven days of movement, adventure, connection, and a little alpine luxury.
Julz and I will be hosting at the gorgeous five-star Das Paradies resort and spa, where we’ll enjoy yoga, strength, hiking, incredible food, spa and sauna time, and exploring the beautiful surrounding region.
The best part? This is your adventure, too. Challenge yourself, slow down, or enjoy a little of both.
We still have room for a few more wonderful humans! Registration is open, and you can save €500 with code ITALYVIP, until Thanksgiving!
Explore the itinerary, pricing, and reserve your spot!
The mountains are waiting. Maybe 2027 is the year you finally say yes to that adventure.
|
How I can help you right now:
- 1:1 Coaching (virtual or in-person): Personalized fitness, nutrition, health, and lifestyle coaching designed to meet you where you are.
- Group Coaching (Elevate 8 + other programs): For everyday athletes who want structure, accountability, and community while building strength and resilience.
- Studio Classes & Training (Tahoe Flow Arts & Fitness): Yoga, strength, aerial, and movement training with an amazing mountain community.
- Retreats & Events: Immersive experiences where movement, mindset, and connection come together.
- Corporate & Team Wellness: Workshops, trainings, and programs designed to support employee health, resilience, and performance, ideal for mountain resorts, hospitality, and other organizations who want to invest in their people.
|
Never Stop Learning:
Get your resources here...